Finance

The RMD Deadline Is December 31, and the Missed-Withdrawal Penalty Changed

Turn 73 and the IRS stops letting your traditional retirement account grow untaxed forever. You have to pull a required amount out by December 31 or face an excise tax on what you failed to take. The penalty used to be a brutal 50 percent. It's lower now, which is exactly why people are getting careless about a deadline that still bites.

Gerald Townsend
Senior Finance EditorNovember 3, 20269 min read
An older woman in glasses reviewing printed financial statements at a table

The Bill for Decades of Deferral Comes Due at 73

A traditional IRA or a pre-tax 401(k) is a deal with the government: contribute pre-tax, let it grow untaxed for decades, and settle up on the way out. The settling-up is not optional, and it is not indefinite. In the year an account holder turns 73, the required minimum distribution begins, an amount the IRS calculates that must leave the account and land on that year's tax return. The deadline for each year's withdrawal is December 31. Investors who spent forty years being told to leave the account alone now have to be told, firmly, to take money out of it.

The age is 73 for anyone born between 1951 and 1959, and 75 for those born in 1960 or later, a staircase written into the SECURE 2.0 Act. The account custodian will usually calculate the required figure and even offer to distribute it automatically. Usually. The ones who get burned are the ones who assumed "usually" meant "always," and it is a specific kind of retiree, organized and self-directed, who turns off the automatic distribution and then forgets he did.

The First Year Has a Trap Dressed as a Favor

There is one exception to the December 31 deadline, and it is the exception that causes the trouble. For the first RMD only, the year the account holder turns 73, the withdrawal can be delayed until April 1 of the following year. It sounds like a courtesy. It is a courtesy that can double the tax bill.

Delay that first distribution to April 1, and the second year's RMD still comes due on December 31 of that same year. Two required distributions, two taxable amounts, stacked into a single calendar year, which can shove the retiree into a higher bracket and inflate the income figure that Medicare uses to set Part B premiums two years later. The deferral did not save tax. It concentrated it. We have seen this movie before, and it usually ends with a surprised phone call to the accountant in March.

The Penalty Got Softer, Which Made People Sloppy

Miss the deadline and the IRS levies an excise tax on the amount that should have come out and didn't. For most of its history this penalty was a punishing 50 percent of the shortfall, one of the harshest numbers in the tax code. SECURE 2.0 cut it to 25 percent, and cut it further to 10 percent if the account holder corrects the shortfall within a two-year correction window and files the right form.

That is real relief, and it has had a predictable side effect: a deadline that used to command genuine fear now gets treated as a soft suggestion. Ten percent is not 50 percent, but 10 percent of a five-figure required distribution is still thousands of dollars in tax on money you were always going to owe tax on anyway, paid on top of the ordinary income tax on the distribution itself. The rule got gentler. It did not get free.

What the Rule Does and Does Not Touch

The requirement applies to traditional IRAs and pre-tax employer plans like a standard 401(k). It does not apply to a Roth IRA during the owner's lifetime, because Roth money was already taxed going in, so the government has no deferred claim to collect. As of the 2024 rule change, Roth 401(k) balances are also no longer subject to lifetime RMDs, which removed an old quirk that used to force retirees to roll Roth 401(k) money to a Roth IRA just to escape a distribution requirement that never made much sense.

The calculation itself is not mysterious: the prior year-end balance divided by a life-expectancy factor from the IRS Uniform Lifetime Table. What trips people is not the arithmetic. It is having multiple traditional IRAs at different custodians and assuming each one handles its own. The required amount is figured across all of them, and while an IRA owner may take the total from any single account, somebody has to add them up. That somebody is you.

The Part Nobody Puts in the Brochure

If a deadline slips, the move is not to panic and it is not to hope the IRS doesn't notice. Take the missed distribution as soon as the mistake surfaces, then file Form 5329 to report the shortfall and request a waiver of the excise tax for reasonable cause. The IRS grants these more readily than its reputation suggests, particularly when the correction was prompt and the error was honest. The softened penalty and the waiver together mean a missed RMD is rarely a catastrophe now.

It is still an unforced error, and the fix is dull. Confirm before December that the distribution is scheduled, from which account, for the correct amount, and that any automatic setting you switched off years ago is not the reason nothing is going to move. The account spent decades growing because you left it alone. The one year that discipline turns into a liability is the year the calendar says take some out, and the calendar does not send a reminder.